Caribbean Vacation Rentals and The PoolClub at Mahogany!

Caribbean Vacation Rentals and The PoolClub at Mahogany! Overview

First Impressions

When I first pulled into Caribbean Vacation Rentals and The PoolClub at Mahogany!, I honestly wasn’t sure what to expect from the name alone. But stepping onto the grounds at Mahogany Bay Village in San Pedro, everything clicked into place. This four-star property feels like someone took the best parts of a vacation rental and combined them with resort-style amenities — and somehow made it work perfectly. The parking situation is refreshingly stress-free too, which you’ll appreciate after navigating Belize’s roads.

Location & Setting

San Pedro sits on Ambergris Caye, and honestly, you couldn’t ask for a better base to explore Belize’s incredible barrier reef. What I love about this spot is that you’re close enough to town to grab dinner or book diving excursions, but far enough out to actually relax. The recent guest rating of 8.1 for location makes total sense — couples especially seem to get it, and I can see why. There’s something about being on an island where golf carts outnumber cars that just puts you in vacation mode immediately.

The Accommodations

The room setup here is where things get interesting. You’re not dealing with typical hotel boxes — these feel more like actual vacation homes where you might stay for a week or two. The spaces have character, and I mean that in the best way possible. You get the privacy and comfort of a rental property, but with the peace of mind that comes with professional management. The air conditioning works (crucial in Belize), and the layouts actually make sense for couples who want to spread out a bit.

The PoolClub Experience

Now, about that PoolClub part of the name — this is where the property really shines. The pool area becomes the social heart of the place, but it never feels crowded or chaotic. You know what I noticed? People actually talk to each other here, maybe because everyone’s in that relaxed Caribbean mindset. The pool itself is well-maintained, and there are enough spots to find your own corner if you’re not feeling social. It’s one of those places where you end up spending way more time than you planned, just because it’s so comfortable.

Why Guests Love It

That 9.0 rating isn’t just a number — you feel it in the details. The staff genuinely seems to care about making sure you’re sorted, whether that’s helping arrange island activities or just pointing you toward the best local spots. What really sets this place apart is how it balances that vacation rental independence with just enough service to make everything smooth. You’re not dealing with stuffy hotel protocols, but you’re also not left to figure everything out on your own. For couples especially, it hits that sweet spot between adventure and relaxation that makes Belize such a special destination.

Caribbean Vacation Rentals and The PoolClub at Mahogany! Accommodations

Reviews of Caribbean Vacation Rentals and The PoolClub at Mahogany!

• Lianne from United Kingdom (8/10)

  The property looked beautiful, clean and the host was very helpful. While the pool was quite small, it was perfect for us with our smallish kids. Bigger kids and adults would struggle to swim in it but it is perfect for a dip.

• Dionna from United States (9/10)

  Very cute and comfy space. Fit five adults perfectly without feeling crowded. The lofted room is warm but not uninhabitable. The place gets pretty cool. The pool is perfect for a night dip. The distance to the pool club is perfect to entice you to get another drink which I wasn’t upset about.

• Morgan from United States (9/10)

  From the assistance before I booked, through when I actually booked, through the entire stay, Melki and Gaby were amazing. They helped with information about golf cart rentals, places to visit, excursions, whats offered with the house, etc. The house was a perfect size for our girl’s trip of 4. The extra bathroom and the “treehouse” (as we called it) was a great part of the house. It’s conveniently located about 10-15 mins away from heart of San Pedro on top of it being a security monitored Airbnb kind of resort. Melki and Gaby literally helped make our trip perfect. I couldn’t have asked for anything better. I most definitely would stay here again and recommend Belize overall.

• Kennuth from Germany (9/10)

• Tamayah from Belize (8/10)

Facilities