Caribbean Lily @ Caribe Island

Caribbean Lily @ Caribe Island Overview

First Impressions

Walking up to Caribbean Lily @ Caribe Island, you immediately get that “this is going to be good” feeling. The four-star property sits right on Ambergris Street in San Pedro, and honestly, the location alone makes it worth considering. I mean, you’re literally steps away from everything that makes this part of Belize special — the Caribbean Sea practically lapping at your doorstep and the laid-back island vibe hitting you the moment you arrive. The building itself has that tropical charm without trying too hard, if you know what I mean.

The Apartment Experience

The one-bedroom setup (I stayed in unit #24) actually feels more spacious than you’d expect from the photos. There’s something refreshing about having your own little slice of island life rather than just another hotel room. The kitchen comes in handy — not that you’ll want to cook much with all the amazing local spots nearby, but it’s nice having the option for morning coffee or storing those Belikin beers you’ll inevitably pick up. The air conditioning works well, which trust me, you’ll appreciate during those humid afternoons.

Location That Actually Matters

Here’s the thing about San Pedro — location is everything, and Caribbean Lily nailed it. You’re close enough to walk to the main strip where all the action happens, but far enough away that you’re not dealing with noise all night. The water taxi dock is just a short stroll, which makes day trips to other cayes ridiculously easy. I found myself walking to restaurants, dive shops, and beach bars without even thinking about it. Plus, if you’re traveling as a couple (which seems to be the sweet spot for this place), the romantic sunset spots are all within easy reach.

What Works and What Doesn’t

The property gets high marks from recent guests for good reason — it delivers on the basics without any major surprises. The WiFi actually works (not always a given in Belize), and the place stays clean throughout your stay. I’ll be honest though, don’t expect resort-level amenities or concierge service. This is more about having a comfortable, well-located base for exploring San Pedro and the surrounding waters. The 7.9 rating feels about right — it’s solid without being spectacular.

Why Guests Love It

What really sets Caribbean Lily apart is how it lets you live like a local while still having tourist-friendly comforts. Couples especially seem to appreciate the privacy and the romantic potential of having your own space so close to the water. You can grab fresh lobster from a local fisherman, cook it in your own kitchen, and eat it watching the sunset — try doing that in a traditional hotel room. The combination of independence, location, and that authentic Belizean island atmosphere makes it work for people who want more than just a place to sleep.

Caribbean Lily @ Caribe Island Accommodations

Reviews of Caribbean Lily @ Caribe Island

• Nsilvaaguayo from Chile (9/10)

  The views are amazing from the balcón, the pool, or the beach. I never knew if I could swim in front of the apartment, because it is without beach.

• Carolyn from United States (9/10)

  location, price

• Toofly from United States (1/10)

  The beach and property itself is beautiful.

• Anna from Germany (8/10)

  direkte Meerlage – sogar vom Bett aus Blick aufs Meer 😀

• Bennet from Germany (8/10)

• S from Germany (9/10)

• Nitay from Israel (9/10)

Facilities